Thumbtack Background Check Mistakes: What to Do If You’re Unfairly Flagged
Thumbtack is a popular platform that connects service professionals with clients looking for everything from plumbing and landscaping to tutoring and personal training. To maintain trust and safety on the platform, Thumbtack runs background checks on many professionals. While this can help weed out legitimate risks, it also leads to serious problems when the Thumbtack background check includes a mistake or error that unfairly flags a user - sometimes even banning them entirely.
If you’ve been denied access or removed from Thumbtack due to a background check, you’re not alone. And you’re not powerless either. In this article, we’ll walk through the types of background check errors that happen, how to file a Thumbtack background check dispute, and when it may be time to consider filing a lawsuit under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).
Have You Been Affected By a Background Check Error?
Contact Us - Our Legal Support Is Free!
What Is a Thumbtack Background Check?
When you create a professional profile on Thumbtack, the platform may run a background check through a third-party company, often Checkr, Evident, or a similar consumer reporting agency. These checks are designed to screen for criminal records and sometimes verify identity and professional licensing.
Depending on the category of service and local laws, a background check may be mandatory. If the background check comes back with any concerns - valid or not, Thumbtack may suspend or permanently deactivate your account without warning.
Common Thumbtack Background Check Mistakes
While background checks sound straightforward, the reality is far messier. The following are common errors that show up on Thumbtack background checks:
Outdated Criminal Records: Even expunged or dismissed charges sometimes appear in reports.
Wrong Person: Your report might reflect someone else’s criminal history due to a similar name or date of birth — a classic case of mistaken identity.
Incomplete Information: A record may be listed as an “open charge” even though it was resolved long ago.
Clerical Mistakes: Typos or mismatched addresses and Social Security numbers can cause inaccurate flags.
False Positives from Other Databases: Sometimes, information from unrelated civil records or court databases gets improperly included.
These background check mistakes can damage your reputation, income, and access to Thumbtack — all without giving you a real chance to explain or fix the situation.
How to File a Thumbtack Background Check Dispute
If your background check contains inaccurate information, you have the right to file a Thumbtack background check dispute. However, it’s important to know that the dispute won’t go through Thumbtack directly — it must be submitted to the company that conducted the check (e.g., Checkr).
Here’s how to start the dispute process:
Get a Copy of Your Background Check
If Thumbtack took action against your account based on a background check, you’re entitled to a copy of that report. Request it immediately through Thumbtack or the third-party provider (usually they’ll give you a link to Checkr or Evident).Review the Report Carefully
Look for any inaccurate charges, dates, or personally identifying information. Compare the details to your official court records and identity documents.Collect Documentation
Gather police reports, court records, expungement papers, or other proof to refute the incorrect information.Submit a Formal Dispute
Submit your dispute in writing to the background check company. Include a clear explanation of the error, your supporting evidence, and identifying details (name, date of birth, etc.). Certified mail is best for tracking.Follow Up
By law, the background check company has 30 days to investigate and correct the issue. Keep records of all communications.
When to File a Lawsuit for a Background Check Error
You may have grounds for a lawsuit against the background check company (not necessarily Thumbtack itself) if:
The report contained inaccurate or outdated information.
The company failed to investigate your dispute properly.
The report caused a denial of work or loss of income.
The background check mixed your file with someone else’s (a “mixed file” case).
You were not properly notified that a background check was being used.
In these cases, you could be entitled to compensation for:
Lost earnings
Emotional distress
Reputational harm
Statutory damages (up to $1,000 per violation)
Attorney’s fees (often covered if you win)
Most consumer protection attorneys handle these cases on a contingency basis, meaning you don’t pay unless you win.
Final Thoughts: Don’t Let a Background Check Mistake Define You
Losing access to Thumbtack because of an inaccurate background check can feel frustrating and unfair — and it is. But you have legal rights. By filing a Thumbtack background check dispute and taking the right steps, you may be able to fix the problem, reclaim your reputation, and even pursue compensation if you’ve suffered damages.
The most important thing is not to ignore it. Every day lost could be income missed, and the sooner you take action, the stronger your case will be. If you suspect your report was wrong — or if Thumbtack won’t give you answers — contact an experienced FCRA attorney to explore your legal options and potentially file a lawsuit to make things right.
What If My Thumbtack Background Check Failed?
Request a Copy of Your Background Check.
You are entitled to a free copy of your background report. You can request it from Checkr or find it in your email if Thumbtack sent a pre-adverse action notice.
Review the Report for Errors.
Carefully review each section of your report and identify any errors or discrepancies, such as unrecognized criminal records, misreported information, or other issues.
Dispute the Error.
You can file a dispute directly through Checkr, but results vary. Disputes are not always effective, especially if the source of the error is a third-party data vendor.
Contact an FCRA Attorney.
If your Thumbtack account was deactivated due to a background check mistake, a Fair Credit Reporting Act attorney can help you correct the report and pursue legal compensation for lost income and emotional distress. You may be eligible for statutory damages, and you don’t pay legal fees out of pocket.
